There is a house within. It is the place where Jesus preached his greatest sermons. It is where Buddha shook hands with enlightenment. It is the hearth where we seek solace and consolation when all around us grief is in its fullest bloom.
So began the first chapter of Dr. D. Watson’s first book, Tearing Down the House Within. You may have read that passage elsewhere. It’s been cited in books of quotations, internet profiles, spiritual anthologies, wedding vows, yearbook pages, blog mastheads, and even Presidential debates. Now does it ring a bell?
You would think, then, that the author would still be cashing fresh fat royalty checks. That he’d at least have a career peddling mystical hoodoo on late night radio call in shows. You certainly wouldn’t think that a man of his long academic career would be living off loans from his former students, or spending his last days exiled in an Italian shack. But there it is. Dr. Watson’s most influential work has been out of print for most of the 32 years since it was published.
Pity the poor professor, but realize, as well, that he had no one but himself to blame. The book suffered a poor reputation because it was, in all honesty, a poor book – poorly argued, poorly organized, poorly concluded. He built up his thesis in the ten brisk pages of his first chapter, and then spent the next 756 pages tearing it down.
For the curious, here is the book briefly: God exists but is hiding, He is like a house within us, we must tear apart this house, and rebuild it on the outside; which is to say, we must build God on earth. There you go, sounds familiar, like any other mystical tome you’d find on cluttered used book store shelves. Except that Dr. Watson wasn’t much of a mystic, or even a believer in spirits or angels or the like. He believed in God as a very real being, with very real power, but lacking the temporal means to act on that power. Somewhere in the calendar of creation, God, having set things in motion, got lost along the way, and was trapped in between existence and nothingness. We mortals, as products of His creation, each have little pieces of Him inside us. When we finally kill the last piece of God within us, we can begin rebuilding Him in our image. We’ll be gods ourselves. We will, in essence, through this process of god-killing, finally realize the highest, most advanced form of civilization for which man is capable. The sad thing is that this summary is more coherent than the arguments contained in the actual book.
As one reviewer put it, “It’s a little like arguing that the best way to find gold is to hunt down and kill all the leprechauns.” Of course, when I wrote that review I would’ve thought it daft if anyone had so much as suggested that I’d later be working for the man – and as his assistant, no less. At the time I thought he was some kind of maniac – an opinion that my nearly twenty years in his service did little to change. And yet it was to me that he entrusted the security of his papers, as well as the perpetuation of his legacy. He knew I didn’t believe in his theories; indeed, he even kept a blown-up copy of my scathing review pinned to the wall of his office.
He called me the “Chief Unbeliever”. Unbeliever, of course, meant anyone who heaped scorn on his theories, or otherwise ridiculed him; since that included most of the sentient creatures on the planet, I was singled out as the most prominent of these. “You stand out,” he told me, “because you alone are a match for my brain. You, my boy, are my intellectual equal.” I should have felt insulted, but his endearing tone always won me over. He’d always been a lonely man, in one way or another, usually because he rejected the ideas of other men, shutting himself up in his own private world. By the time I met him, he was a nearly broken man, ridiculed by his peers, and no longer lonely by choice. He was ill, and desperate for human companionship. It would’ve been rude—not to mention callous—to reject him.
“There, do you see it?” We’d just made it to the top of the hill, and Mr. Watson was pointing ahead of us. The rain was still coming down, and it was dark all around, but if you strained your eyes you could see the faint lights of a small house.
“Oh, sweet Jesus, I thought we’d never make it,” said Trevor, or possibly Terrence. I didn’t know which it was to my left or right.
All I could say, weakly through my still-sore throat, was “At last…at last.”
We made our way up the final path to the professor’s cabin, Sophia leading the way. I kept picturing him from our last contentious meeting five years earlier. He was old and dying then, and now I wondered if I’d be there when the lights of his own house within were finally dimmed.